Table of Contents

A lender contacts a firm and requests financial statements prepared with a review engagment report. A week later, an investor asks: “Has the company ever been audited?” For business owners in Alberta, this moment may have come before you, and chances are you weren’t completely sure of the implications for your profits.
It’s understandable that there’s some confusion. They’re both assurance services; they both create statements signed by a CPA’s name, and they both provide outsiders with assurance over your numbers. It can cost thousands of dollars and weeks of time to make the wrong choice.
This article explains the differences between the services, what each service entails and how to determine which one your business needs.

What is a Review Engagement?

Review engagement is a type of limited assurance. Your CPA conducts analytical procedures and inquires of management to make judgments as to whether statements are reasonable and otherwise compiles the financial statements without performing tests of internal controls or independently verifying every transaction.
It’s more of an a structured professional assessment than a proper investigation. The accountant is the one who checks the numbers and investigates any discrepancies. If everything adds up, they report that nothing has come to their attention to indicate that the statements are materially misstated.
In general, reviews are selected by:
  • Small and medium enterprises (SMEs) 
  • Enterprises having simple loan terms 
  • Shareholders who wish for assurance but do not complete audit fees. 
  • Businesses that are not required to have an audit per regulation or contract. 
Review engagements are not as extensive and often take less time and cost than an audit because of that. A review is a good compromise for many private Alberta businesses.

What Is an Audit?

An audit offers reasonable assurance, which is a higher level of assurance than a review’s limited assurance. Your auditor independently gathers evidence, tests transactions and balances, and evaluates internal controls.
It involves checking stock levels, reconciling your accounts with your source and your clients, signing invoices to source and reviewing the reliability of your systems. The result is an audit opinion: a formal statement that, in all material respects, the financial statements fairly present your financial position in the framework.
Audits require more time, more paperwork from your team and a higher fee. In return, they provide lenders, investors and regulators with the utmost comfort a CPA firm can offer.
Factor Review Engagement Audit 
Objective Assess plausibility of financial statements Form an opinion on fair presentation 
Assurance level Limited assurance Reasonable assurance 
Procedures Analytical review, inquiry Testing, verification, confirmation 
Internal controls Not evaluated Assessed as part of risk approach 
Cost Lower Higher 
Time required Shorter Longer, more disruptive to staff 
Reporting Review engagement report Independent auditor’s report 
Best suited for Smaller private companies, straightforward financing Larger, complex, or regulated organizations 
Typical users Lenders, minority shareholders Investors, regulators, public stakeholders 
In practice, it’s about the depth of the verification. The review provides limited assurance for stakeholders. An audit is a test that tells them that the numbers have been tested independently.

When is a Review Engagement Necessary for your Business?

A review engagement typically occurs when:
  • You are only required to submit reviewed statements, not audited statements, by your lender’s covenants. 
  • If your shareholder agreement does not require reasonable assurance, it requires only limited assurance. 
  • You don’t want public capital; you want bank funding.
  • Revenue recognition and multiple subsidiaries are not involved in operations.
  • You’d like to get credible statements without total audit costs and time.
In Alberta, the majority of the family businesses and owner-managed companies are able to accommodate review-level engagements for several years before transitioning to the audit level when growth levels, financing or ownership changes arise.

When Is an Audit the Better Choice?

An audit is the appropriate course of action if:
  • It is required by regulation, like some non-profit or regulated industries
  • Investors or private equity partners are putting a lot of money at risk.
  • The lender is providing a large facility and wishes to have the best available assurance. 
  • Audited statements are required for government funding or grant conditions. 
  • Multiple location controls are needed for independent testing due to the complexity of the business. 
  • You need to prepare for a sale, merger or offering that requires an audited history for valuation purposes. 
Often, growth is the trigger. Stakeholders may have higher expectations for a business, especially one that has outgrown the reporting level of reviews.

Questions to Ask Before Choosing

When deciding on either service, you should ask yourself the following questions:
  • What does my lender or investor need to sign?
  • Do I have a legal requirement for my entity type or industry to conduct an audit?
  • What level of assurance does stakeholders really require?
  • What is the reasonable amount I can spend on assurance fees for this year? 
  • Are my operations, revenues, and business entity complex?
  • Will these requirements change in the coming years due to growth or financing plans?

Common Misconceptions

Review engagement is simply bookkeeping. It is not. Review involves professional analysis and a formal CPA report.
All businesses require an audit. Most private firms will never require one unless a lender, investor or regulator asks for it.
Audits ensure that fraud is detected. An audit is not a fraud investigation; it helps to minimize the risks of material misstatement.
A review is as good as an audit. Limited and reasonable assurance are distinct levels of assurance.

Conclusion

There is no universally correct choice between a review engagement and an audit. It depends on the needs of your investors and lenders, applicable regulations, growth plans, and budget. Either failing to get it right, paying an unnecessary audit fee, or skipping a stakeholder’s requirements will cost money.

How Faber LLP Can Help

Faber LLP serves private enterprises throughout the province of Alberta, identifying the appropriate level of assurance and then providing it with efficiency. Our team conducts review engagements and audits for owner-managed firms, expanding businesses and those ready for financing, acquisition, or succession.
We begin by determining what assurance your lenders, investors, or regulators truly require, and you don’t pay for more or less than your stakeholders need. Our team takes care of the engagement from there, communicating and keeping to the schedule.
In addition to the engagement itself, Faber LLP provides clients with financial reporting, business advisory and growth planning services so today’s assurance decision aligns with where your business is going next. If you are not certain whether your business needs a review engagement or an audit, our team can assist you in determining it with confidence.

Leave A Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *